Marine Pollution Bulletin 194 (2023) 115396
8
older sediment reservoirs (legacy pollution) due to changing current
conditions in the direct surrounding of the individual foundations might
be possible.
Temporal variations of the measured Zn mass fraction are very small
for the areas N-2, N-3 and N-6 over the studied timeframe indicating no
increase of mass fractions of Zn in sediments within the vicinity of
OWFs. The largest variations can be observed for area N-4. Indeed, Zn
mass fractions in most of the analyzed sediment samples are above the
NOAA ERL indicating potential effects on the marine environment.
Some marine species are reported to be very sensitive to increased Zn
concentrations in the water phase (Peganova and Eder, 2004), including
changes in growth of marine cyanobacteria (Sarker et al., 2021). The
continuous release of anode material has the potential to further in-
crease environmental concentrations. As Zn is the second most abundant
element in Al based galvanic anodes a release of 1600 kg to 3600 kg Zn
in each OWF area can be conservatively estimated, considering five
years and 150 offshore wind turbines per OWF area. Zn is a so-called
recycled or nutrient type element in the context of seawater, hence,
long residence times in seawater (103–105 years) are typical (Kremling
et al., 1999) and enrichments are more likely to be observed in the water
phase. Long-term monitoring data by the BSH (2016) shows that
elevated mass fractions of Zn in the German North Sea were observed
even before the construction of the first OWFs in 2012 (BSH, 2016),
likely due to other sources such as shipping (OSPAR, 2009), river dis-
charges (Reese et al., 2019; Zimmermann et al., 2019a), or, especially
for OWF area N-4 located north of Heligoland, historical dumping of
dilute acid waste until 1989 (BSH, 1991; Pickaver, 1982). Due to the
very complex source situation and the long residence time of Zn in
seawater, the current Zn pollution in the OWF areas under consideration
cannot be clearly attributed to new emissions of OWFs.
In contrast to the legacy pollutants Cd, Zn and Pb, the TCEs Ga and In
can be considered emerging contaminants with almost no currently
known anthropogenic sources into the marine environment (Romero-
Freire et al., 2019). Both elements are added to galvanic anode alloys to
avoid passivation of the Al surface and hence promote the dissolution of
the anode instead of the steel structure. For a five year protection of one
OWF area of 150 coated offshore wind turbines the release of 5 kg to 8
kg Ga and 9 kg to 14 kg In can be estimated (Reese et al., 2020). Like Pb,
Ga and In are assumed to be particle-active elements in seawater,
meaning that these elements are transported over the particulate matter
into the sediments with short resident times in seawater (Klein et al.,
2022b; Kremling et al., 1999; Romero-Freire et al., 2019). All median
mass fractions of Ga are within the range of North Sea sediments as
published by Klein et al. (2022a). Median mass fractions are higher in
the areas N-2 and N-6 for 2021, but decrease again in 2022. The highest
inter-year variability for Ga can be observed for area N-4. Very similar
observations can be made for In: All In median mass fractions are within
the range of North Sea Sediments as published by Klein et al. (2022a).
The highest inter-year variability for In can be observed for area N-4
with the highest values in 2020, decreasing in 2021 and 2022. Similarly,
area N-2 features highest mass fractions in 2021, but decreased to mass
fractions similar to 2018 and 2019 in 2022. This might be also caused by
the high known sea bed dynamics in the German Bight (Zeiler et al.,
2008), which results also in the spatial transport and dispersion of fresh
pollutant-loaded sediments.
4.2. Spatial distribution of Indium mass fractions
The spatial distribution of elemental mass fractions in and around
OWFs area N-4 will be discussed in detail in this chapter, as it features
the highest sample density over the longest time period during this
study, combined with the highest intra-year variability for the tracer
elements. As In is the most promising tracer for anode emissions, the
spatial distribution is discussed for In, as shown in Fig. 4. Corresponding
maps for all other tracer elements (Cd, Pb, Zn, Ga) can be found in ESM
Figs. A2, A5, A8, A11. As can be seen from the first sampling campaign
in 2016 (Fig. 4A) the distribution of In mass fractions seems to follow a
North-South gradient with higher elemental mass fractions in the
northern region (140 ?g kg 1 30 ?g kg 1 to 190 ?g kg 1 40 ?g kg 1)
compared to the southern region (80 ?g kg 1 20 ?g kg 1 to 130 ?g
kg 1 10 ?g kg 1). However, this was not necessarily true for all five
following sampling campaigns in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022
(Fig. 4B–F). Recent literature indicates an increase of metal concentra-
tion with decreasing distance to the wind farm center (Wang et al.,
2023). In our study the highest In mass fractions occurred in 2020
(marked dark red in Fig. 4D). High In mass fractions (light red) were
found in 2016, 2019, 2020 and 2021, again outside or at the edge of the
OWF, except for 2019. Indium mass fractions in 2019 (Fig. 4C) show a
Fig. 3. (A) Isotope ratio n(87Sr)/n(86Sr) plotted against the inverse Sr mass fraction. The purple area corresponds to data from Elbe estuary sediments (Reese et al.,
2019). (B) Share of the <20 ?m grain size fraction in the sediment samples plotted against the isotope ratio n(87Sr)/n(86Sr). The data points are grouped into the
respective OWF areas. Error bars correspond to expanded uncertainties U(k ? 2) for isotope ratios and inverse mass fractions and to standard deviation (n ? 3) for the
grain size fraction. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
A. Ebeling et al.